Sunday, February 3, 2013

My Annual Teaching Evaluation

I would like to take up a little blog space with a weekly feature examining the teaching evaluation process. Last week was my annual teaching evaluation. Every year I look forward to the event as it my chance to showcase what I do everyday. As a level III master teacher in New Mexico, I am required to have the instructional quality of my teaching practices scrutinized only once per year. As much as I harp on the fact that the number one factor in a students learning is parental involvement studies also show (most famously a study by Stanford professor Linda Darling-Hammond) that the number one factor AT SCHOOL is teacher effectiveness, and I agree. The evaluation process is intended to ensure that the school side of things are taking care of business. However, I find most of the evaluation process ineffective, and here's why. To begin with, let's examine the process of scheduling an administrator to come into a classroom and observe ones teaching. At my school, as in many others I suspect, the teacher signs up for a specific date, and is given weeks and weeks of advanced notice and coaching on lesson plans, pedagogy development, hands-on activity practice, etc. In other words, it is quite common for a worksheet King or Queen (that's school speak for crappy teacher) to schedule a very innovative Dog and Pony Show/lesson once or twice per year (depending upon ones level of licensure). After their evaluation, in which the administrator applauds what a wonderful teacher/King/Queen they are, many (most) ineffective teachers devolve back into the instructional path of least resistance, from whence they came: worksheets, word finds, crossword puzzles, and other canned curriculum resources that result in very little learning. These are the ineffective teachers who believe that giving assignments, talking for 45 minutes, and teaching/learning are the same thing. Incredulously, they exclaim, "What? How in the world did you fail that test? I mean, I talked every day and you took notes...how could learning not have occurred??" Then, they roll their eyes and just can't believe how "kids are these days." Instead, I find the idea of scheduling my evaluation to be disingenuous. It is not fair for the teacher, the process, or the students who must continue to have these poor teachers. I have instructed my administrator to come in whenever they wish (they still insist that I sign up, though), and do a "pop" eval. I've told them to bring guests from around the district (politicians, parents, superintendents) and to bring cameras and record my teaching. After all, shouldn't I be on my "A" game everyday, and not just as scheduled? Shouldn't every lesson included learning standards and objectives? Obviously, I am not on my "A" game everyday, but neither is any human being. I think that is normal in any career. I don't think it is unreasonable. I don't think it is anything to fear. Let me know what you think in the comments section.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Preach on Sister!



Anyone with more than three years of teaching experience, I think, would not find this as a big surprise. While the teacher may be the biggest factor in the classroom, out of the classroom the student and parents are the biggest factor.
Society in general would say, "You mean, if you refuse to study, refuse to complete assignments, labs, and projects, you can't just magically be MADE smart by the teacher? Really?"

Ummm...yes...Really.

Tuesday, January 4, 2011

Education reform: number two of eight school chiefs to watch in 2011

Our next "magic bullet" candidate is Janet Barresi (R), new superintendent of public instruction in Oklahoma. She is a former school speech pathologist, dentist, and founder of a charter school. She opposed a ballot question that would have increased funding for Oklahoma schools, saying it would require big cuts to other agencies and that schools should instead be run with more efficiency.
Her agenda includes increasing the rigor of the state curriculum to ensure that students are ready for both college and careers. Ms. Barresi also wants to revise testing requirements.
“We should be looking at using a handful of reliable and proven instruments, like the ACT and the Iowa tests, and not the mishmash of standardized tests ... the state now has,” she told CapitorlBeatOK, a news service at the Oklahoma capitol.
While the article is far from a comprehensive representation of her philosophy, from what is featured I find little to disagree with. Are schools run inefficiently? Absolutely! Never have I seen so many assistant assistants using their local school district as their own personal cash cow. Or small class A or B districts with a superintendent and vice-superintendent? C'mon...seriously? But it is reality. In the 80s, when faced with competition from Japan, the big auto companies in America thought the way to compete was to cut all the WORKERS, but keep their seven vice-presidents of marketing. Likewise, school administration is following suit. Got budget problems and three superintendents? No worries...just ditch the art program!
As for her comment regarding the mishmash of standardized tests, I again couldn't agree more wholeheartedly. If, as educators, our ultimate goal is to encourage as many students as possible to attend post-secondary institutions, then we should be teaching LIKE post-secondary institutions and preparing students for the tests that will get them IN the college of their choice.
Here in New Mexico, where 40% of high school seniors have to take remedial math classes as college freshmen, we continue to shove Connected Math (the math program that is responsible for the remedial math enrollment) down the throats of students, teachers, and VERY confused parents. I for one have experienced a couple of students angrily exclaiming, after seeing their college dreams evaporate, "There wasn't a DAMN bit of Connected Math on the ACT." While my personal evidence is very anecdotal in nature, there is much to suggest that this "new" math, this "fuzzy" math, shows NO improvement.
My pre-test grade for Ms. Barresi is a good solid B+. Let's see how she does later in the semester.

Education reform: number one of eight school chiefs to watch in 2011

Happy New Year! It's time to look forward to another year of finger pointing, teacher bashing, and false solutions by bureaucrats who don't want to anger voters by saying, "Parents....we can't do it without you" *Sigh* Well, let the parade of inept politicians begin.
Our first Mr. Fix-it is Jason Glass of Iowa. Appointed to be the new director of the Iowa Department of Education by Gov.-elect Terry Branstad (R), Jason Glass is a former teacher and school administrator. In Eagle County, Colo., where he was human resources director, he helped bridge divides when the school system set up a merit pay plan for teachers, the Des Moines Register reports. He now wants to bring that experience to bear on how teachers in Iowa are evaluated and paid.
Overall, he says, he wants to “allow for greater innovation in schools.... That happens by not imposing greater central control on schools, but actually freeing up local school districts to try new things,” he told the Register.
Yes, that's a fabulous idea Jason. Surely, with more local control, students will begin to study and stop bullying the smart kids and calling them nerds. This idea is so innovative, that it is only 200 years old, as featured in this Educational Leadership article from November 1980. Great job Jason! You're on the cutting edge and those scores are gonna skyrocket! However, YOU get an F on your pre-test as Education director for Iowa. Later in the "semester," I sure hope your grade is higher so it will average out to passing.

Saturday, December 18, 2010

Parents Blamed Most Often For Failing Education System, Poll Finds

Blaming teachers for low test scores, poor graduation rates and the other ills of American schools has been popular lately, but a new survey wags a finger closer to home.

An Associated Press-Stanford University Poll on education found that 68 percent of adults believe parents deserve heavy blame for what's wrong with the U.S. education system - more than teachers, school administrators, the government or teachers unions.

Only 35 percent of those surveyed agreed that teachers deserve a great deal or a lot of the blame. Moms were more likely than dads - 72 percent versus 61 percent - to say parents are at fault. Conservatives were more likely than moderates or liberals to blame parents.

Those who said parents are to blame were more likely to cite a lack of student discipline and low expectations for students as serious problems in schools. They were also more likely to see fighting and low test scores as big problems.

"Nobody is too busy to raise a child for a successful future," said Wilfred Luise Vincent, 65, of Coppell, Texas. Vincent worked early or late shifts for Delta Airlines during most of his career so his two daughters would have a parent at home after school.

Now he's retired and home after school to help guide his granddaughter while his daughter works.

The problems children and their parents deal with inside and outside of school every day are growing, said Julie Woestehoff, executive director of Parents United for Responsible Education, a Chicago advocacy group.
Story continues below
Advertisement

Children are tired, they're hungry and they need someone to help with their homework. Some kids face violence at home or in their neighborhood. Some parents are trying so hard to keep a roof over their family that they can't help with school.

More than half of those polled said student discipline and fighting, violence and gangs were extremely or very serious problems in schools. Nearly as many expressed concern about getting and keeping good teachers.

Most said education in their local public schools is excellent or good, but 67 percent also believe the U.S. is falling behind the rest of the world when it comes to education.

But a majority of parents see improvement in the system since they were in school: 55 percent believe their children are getting a better education than they did, and three-quarters rate the quality of education at their child's school as excellent or good. Most say their child's school is doing a good job preparing students for college, the work force and life as an adult.

A variety of research in past years backs up the poll respondents' sense that parenting plays key roles in school performance.

One in 10 kindergarten and first-grade students misses a month of school every year, which can put them behind their classmates for years, according to Attendance Counts, an advocacy group. By ninth grade, missing 20 percent of school is a better predictor of a student dropping out than test scores are, said Attendance Counts director Hedy Chang. In the poll, 41 percent said students not spending enough time in school is a serious problem.

Exposing kids under 2 to too much television can cause them to develop language skills later, researchers at the University of Washington have found.

Hungry students do worse on standardized tests and are absent more often, according several studies that have connected poor nutrition with students who have trouble concentrating.

Educating parents about how the school system works and welcoming them to get involved may also help their children, according to Joyce L. Epstein, research professor of sociology at Johns Hopkins University, who focuses on school, family and community partnerships.

"Without programs to educate parents, everyone is working in some stage of ignorance." Epstein said.

Some things just can't be fixed by schools or even the community, says Mike Principe, 62, of Melrose Park, a suburb of Chicago, Ill.

In addition to worrying about school violence, a lack of student discipline, low expectations for achievement, difficulty attracting good teachers and unimpressive student test scores, Principe is concerned about divorce, the economy, single parents and the national debt.

"These are tough times we're living in," Principe said. "What's our world going to be like when our 2-year-old is an adult?"

The AP-Stanford Poll on Education was conducted Sept. 23-30 by Abt SRBI, Inc. It involved interviews on landline and cellular telephones with 1,001 adults nationwide and has a margin of sampling error of plus or minus 3.9 percentage points.

Stanford's participation in this project was made possible by a grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

___

Online:

AP polls: http://surveys.ap.org

Attendance Counts: http://www.attendancecounts.org/

Parents United for Responsible Education: http://www.pureparents.org/

Johns Hopkins University program on school partnerships: http://partnershipschools.org