Saturday, March 16, 2013

We've Pretty Much Had Enough


I really enjoy reading Diane Ravitch's blog. If you are an educator and you do not read it...you should. Often, her blog is so well written, it makes me think, "What am I doing this for? She says everything I think and feel and often times even better than I could!"
Recently, I've been battling with the idea of quitting teaching. Teaching isn't going anywhere, and I can go and make real money for 10 years or so while these imbeciles try to repair the variable that isn't broken. Then, as an older man in my 50's, I can return to the classroom and not have to worry about laboring away in the elements. As I continue to struggle with my decision, I stumble upon many "I quit" letters from teachers. The disturbing part is, we are all experiencing the same events and attitudes that make us say, "Screw this!" Teachers are the bad guys, teachers have it easy, teachers are lazy, teachers are the only thing in the way of poor little students and their learning. The parents and the students have done everything they can (actually, nothing at all) ....but it's the mean ol' teachers that stifle them at every turn. Boohoo! *sniff* The following is a letter from a colleague. Yet another who has had enough. It echos my sentiments, and, I think, pretty much the sentiments of any teacher:
I feel that we as teachers have really had enough, and that someone needs to finally speak up. My name is Abby Breaux and I have been teaching for 25 years in Lafayette Parish, yet no one in this room knows me because no one here has ever come to the schools in which I’ve taught and just asked me, “What do you as a teacher think?”
I keep hearing statements that only ineffective teachers are leaving the system. This upsets me. Many, and I mean many, teachers like me who have been evaluated as effective and highly effective for many years by their administration are leaving the public schools. These are teachers that have been elected Teacher of the Year, LEF [Lafayette Education Foundation] winners, and many have received other awards. Even more than that, we have played a part in hundreds of thousands of students becoming great citizens and grownups! Teachers have also been criticized for leaving during the year, for interrupting the students learning. But, these teachers have had enough, and many are actually getting physically sick and can’t make it to the end.
Teachers are not the bad guys here. You tell society that we have three months off in the summer and get off at 3:30 in the afternoon. Well, I can tell you for a fact that we work at least 10 months a year. What about all the teachers that either get to school early or stay late? We give up a lot of time for our school children- sometimes our students are getting more time than our families. What about all of us who still after 25 or more years, are working all day and then are working more hours at night? What about all the hours we volunteer to coach, chaperone dances, plan field trips, and sponsor clubs? We stay late after school for meetings and programs, and we are constantly grading papers, at night, on weekends, and even on vacations. We attend in-services for either no or minimal pay in the summer or on weekends. Not to mention all of our OWN MONEY we spend on students. I can’t tell you how many THOUSANDS of dollars I have spent over the years for science and social studies supplies for my classroom alone.
Buying our own paper and ink, team celebrations, class rewards, incentives, classroom decorations, primary sources, books, etc…. And if you think that doesn’t happen. Again, ask a real classroom teacher! So don’t tell me that teachers don’t care!
No one ever really asks us what the real problems are, nor do they ask US how to solve them. You’ve hired people from a state that is #50 in the rankings to fill our positions. I could almost understand if you got someone from a state ranked in the top 10! We have plenty of experience and highly qualified professionals right here in Lafayette Parish. If they are not applying for the job, then the question needs to be asked. WHY?
You make us pilot all of these new programs year after year that have been tried already (just under another name), not worked-and tried again. We keep reinventing the wheel! I hear often that teachers don’t teach any more. We don’t!
You have made us information pushers, test givers, and paper passer outers. LET US TEACH!!! You have taken all of this away. You give us a new common core curriculum that is almost impossible to finish in a year, and now you slide in Compass, new evaluations, JPams, and On Course all in a single year, and all which require more time that we just don’t have. You are setting teachers up to fail. Teaching was once a noble and creative profession. Learning was once fun! If you want kids to stay in school, make them want to come!!!
Our jobs should not depend on two lessons a year. Principals should be able to walk into a classroom any time and do a true evaluation. To tell children that OUR jobs depend on them-well you are giving the students the “upper hand”!
They now have the power and they know it. I have heard some students say that they are not even going to try on the standardized tests. They are even “out” for some teachers and are going to score low on purpose. Many students won’t do their homework or study for tests-WHY? They know they won’t fail because of your policies. You have made it all about “what the teacher needs to do” instead of “what the student needs to do!” HOLD them responsible! Would a doctor lose his job if his diabetic patient didn’t follow their recommendations for losing weight when that patient is hospitalized for his/her choices? Of course not! The educational system is no different. We should not be held responsible for apathy and wrong choices!
If you really want to change one thing in our school system-start with discipline: SIMPLE nothing else, just DISCIPLINE. Follow through from first grade on up to twelfth grade. Be consistent, give consequences. Teachers should not be repeating rules to the same students over and over again. If you would listen to experienced teachers who have good discipline, it works and learning is going on. No fancy programs, no bells and whistles, just the teacher in charge. Stop moving students from school to school. This just dilutes other schools!
You are hiding the problems-NOT solving them! The same students that we saw get away with the “little infractions” over and over, and over again, are the same students that end up in the paper under “local arrests”. We are not here to be popular or please parents, we are here to teach children. Small things like uniforms, gum chewing, and tardies may seem small to you, but to a classroom teacher they are the small things that lead to larger problems like disrespect. If you don’t back us up on these issues, the students know it and lose respect for us. Don’t give in half way through the year, or keep changing things. Follow through. Back your teachers up! You have taken our “power” away. No Discipline=No Teaching-Period!
You have basically taken “morals” and work ethics out of ours schools, yet now our tax money is paying for students to go to private schools where they teach morals and work ethics. I believe we should bring BOTH back to our schools, and this will bring our students back as well.
You want to save one child by not removing them from the classroom or campus because you don’t want THAT child to miss out on learning, but you are doing a TOTAL injustice to the average and above average students who want to learn and know how to behave. The others are NOT learning because teachers are spending their time repeatedly correcting, constantly documenting, meeting one on one, and conferencing with the one child who chooses not to behave. I have about 10 daily behavior plans with only 2 out of the 10 working. Why is this? There is no follow through at home! Teachers work harder than the parents and the child to help that child succeed. If you do not think this is true, again, just ask a classroom teacher!
All teachers are different and that is what makes public education so special. Students get the affection, nurturing, life lessons, and education from each of them over their twelve years. Some experiences will be good, some not so good, but that is called life!!! Children need to learn to cope! They need this skill for the rest of their lives, so they can become good problem solvers on their own and not have everything catered and changed to their every desire. Having their parents just being able to call the central office and have teachers give in to “solve the problem” to make it easier for the child is not a coping skill. You are doing the students and parents a total injustice.
Computers have been an asset in the classroom as a learning tool for students. The school board and state however seem to have incorporated them as tools for teachers to do more meaningless work! We should have computers and laptops for the students to use as resources, not for teachers to type and retype and retype again. You would not want us asking students to redo a project three times and then never grade it. Why do you keep giving us surveys and paperwork that you will never read? A perfect example is our VAM [value-added measures] Evaluations! All of this is taking away from our teaching time!
Is there a reason why we in Lafayette Parish (a parish that has MONEY compared to most) still cannot get enough books for our students in the classroom, yet we have money to waste on silly job positions and in services. This is not just this year or last year; this has been an ongoing occurrence. Teachers should not have to scrape and scramble for books and paper every year! To you this might be minor, but for us, the classroom teachers, this is a major issue and affects morale.
If you think getting rid of experienced classroom teachers is the answer, then shame on you! It takes experienced teachers to help new, inexperienced teachers with the overwhelming burdens of classroom management, helping with background knowledge of the information being taught, and learning how to build relationships with the students and the community that these students come from. There is SO much more to teaching then getting in front of a class and giving a lesson!
Personally, I was hoping to teach for at least 30 years, but because of all these new evaluation policies, fear of retirement issues, and feeling constantly threatened that if I don’t do “this or that” I will lose my job, I and many others have had enough and feel the need to leave. I LOVE TEACHING and never thought this day would come. I love working with kids. You have basically pushed me and many excellent, effective teachers out of the education field or into the private sector with all of your useless paperwork and lack of follow through. I know I may get some “recoil” for what I am saying today, but what I am saying is the truth, and it is something that most teachers say and think every day. Many are afraid to speak up and this is something that I too have been holding in for years because of the same reason. Please, sit down with the CLASSROOM teachers and work with them. But above all, GO TO A CLASSROOM! Don’t choose a “favored, high scoring” school. Go to a struggling school and observe a classroom. Better yet, since you are supposed to be people of “service”, substitute in a classroom. Your eyes will be opened to how difficult it is to do this job on a daily basis.
I am very proud to have worked with the many amazing and hardworking teachers, administrators and staff over the years in Lafayette Parish. We want a positive system and a system that continues to improve as much or even MORE than you. We would really like for you to not only hear us, but make some necessary changes.
Thank you,
Abby Breaux

Monday, February 25, 2013

A Light Reprieve from the Grind of Teaching

Alt_Edukation is a serious blog, because American education is in serious trouble. But it doesn't mean that sometimes we can't look at things lightheartedly. I usually don't post things like this, but today I really needed a break from the serious:


You Might Be a Schoolteacher if...
  
...you have no time for a life from August to June.

...you want to punch the next person who says, "Must be nice to work from 8 to 3 and have your summers free!"

...when out in public you feel the urge to talk to strange children and correct their behavior.

...you refer to adults as "boys and girls."

...you encourage your spouse by telling them they are a "good helper."

...you've ever had your profession criticized by someone who would never dream of doing your job.

...meeting a child's parents instantly answers the question, "Why is this kid like this?"

...you believe "extremely annoying" should have its own box on the report card.

...you know hundred good reasons for being late.





Sunday, February 24, 2013

But...But...it's *sniffle* for the children


Politicians, and school administrators like to wipe away a tear, and, with lips trembling say "it's for the children," especially during election years. But as every good investigator knows, to see where ones priorities really lie, just follow the money and not their words.
It seems every year a group of Americans, and it's probably even the same group, flies over to the same school in Finland and asks, "So what are you guys doing that we are not?"
I especially enjoy the "oh-not-these-guys-again" look on the faces of the Finns. Yeah, ummm...didn't we already tell you for the last three years (1) pay teachers well, treat them like and trust them to be professionals, (2) stop testing every other week, and (3) attract the top, not bottom, 10% of your college graduates and give them top notch training to be successful in the classroom (see step 1 above...again)?
And so, the American education ambassadors gleefully catch their flight, excited about the news with which they shall usher in a golden age, a renaissance, of education in America. And then, suddenly, perhaps they travel through some Bermuda Triangle-like memory eraser. Their planes land, they disembark, and run to Washington to cut all education spending and introduce marketplace competition into public schools. Vouchers, "research" driven curriculum, charter schools, the use of tests to measure teachers; all a philosophy that the Finns watch from overseas and promptly shake their heads in disbelief. What's the Finnish word for, *facepalm*?

Some 'Cyber Schools' Falling Short

Cyberschool isn't for everyone. I've taken online courses, and while I don't hate them, I much prefer the face-to-face time in a classroom. NPR recently featured a story highlighting K12 . In case you didn't already know, K12 is "the number one choice in K-12 online education programs in America." Apparently, critics see many "irregularities" in their test scores as opposed to the wonderous progress they claim they can make. Administrators and politicians, who looked upon K12 as yet another magic bullet, are disappointed that K12 didn't just fix everything with a wave of their wand. But how are these people surprised?
Here's my personal experience, one that is not too uncommon, say, three to four times a year: A student comes to my class, and doesn't do the assignments, doesn't study, doesn't follow the rules, causes problems, doesn't seek additional after-school tutoring, and on and on and on. Of course during the parent/teacher conference, this is a result of my poor teaching and my over all poor performance as a decent human being in general (I'm mean, I yell, I spit in their faces and kick them in the groin when they try to turn in assignments, and other absurdities.)
The student is then transferred to the other 8th grade science teacher and promptly doesn't do the assignments, doesn't study, doesn't follow the rules, causes problems, doesn't seek additional after-school tutoring, and on and on and on.
"Well," snorts the parent, "It's obvious that you all hate my poor baby. I'm going to home school him/her'" and the parent walks up to the guidance counselor and signs them out of school.
To successfully complete an online course, one needs certain skills and attitudes. Can you work independently? Can you ask questions and be persistent until you find out the information you need? Can you meet a deadline?
Now, think back to our student and parent of the year duo. Do they sound like they possess those kinds of skills? The short answer is, of course, no, and THAT is why they don't succeed IN school or OUT. A student who refuses to work with a teacher lording over them sure as hell isn't going to work while mom is out of the house from 8am-5pm.
And so, inevitably the parent returns the student to us the following new school year (even more behind than ever), complete with how the Cyberschools were "out to get her." Perhaps next time I might just explain to her, "Ma'am, maybe K12 Cyberschools just hates your poor baby....like the rest of us."

Friday, February 22, 2013

Finally! Merit pay for teachers in New Mexico!


As we all know, teachers do what they do because of the opportunities they have to strike it rich. Much like the "talent" on Wall Street, you remember them? You know, the ones who nose-dived our entire economy? Anyway, much like them the more financial incentives there are for teachers, the more likely there will be superior testing results.
After all, if you don't pay someone top dollar, they just won't work for you. For example, the executives at Goldman Sachs, Bank of America, Bear Stearns, and Lehman Brothers, all were acting upon financial incentives to ensure that their companies were the cream of the crop. Let's look at Bear Stearns for example. They were in the middle of the financial crisis, but as a result of their financial incentives, they came out of the crisis with....wait, no...ummmm...ok...forget about Bear Stearns. So, what was I saying? Oh yes, financial incentives equal better results. Okay, so, uhhh, take Lehman Brothers...yes, Lehman Brothers! Because they were paid according to their performance, during the financial crisis they were....wait...where is Lehman Brothers? They still exist, right? No? Huh...weird. Ok, well forget about all of that, because regardless of what happens on the free market stage of Wall Street, it will surely work in public schools.
And even if it doesn't, or even if there is NO evidence for the effectiveness of merit pay, the state of New Mexico announced today that they are going to try it.
Again, we have MORE reform, based on old ideas with no evidence, that address an issue that is not a problem. Here's an idea? Why not try "student merit pay?" After all, aren't they the ones who have to study? Don't they have to complete the assignments?
Also, why don't we apply this idea to other areas? Shouldn't we give our soldiers merit pay? If so, wouldn't we get more kills per bullet? I mean, sure they are doing a great job of killing terrorists, but imagine how much better our results would be if they were paid PER terrorist killed? Or, let's have congress on board with this? The current approval rating for Congress is about 15%. If we are going to base teacher pay on approval rating (from parents and administrators) along with test scores, shouldn't we also do the same with other public employees? Especially those who pass laws that impact the same teachers? I think so. That means, with a current salary of $174,000 and an approval rating of 15%, our representatives SHOULD be receiving $26,100 per year. Based on what I'VE seen concerning their competence, that's still a bit high.

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

A Florida Student Speaks Truth to Power

(reprinted from Dianeravitch.net) I am a high school student who attends a public school in Seminole County and I applaud you for this blog. This past year especially I have felt as if every other second I’m being force-fed a meaningless statistic about how wonderful the education is in Florida and how we are excelling by leaps and bounds, while I watch teachers and students alike suffer the consequences of these careless political decisions. Our school’s media center is also a “Hub for Technology” computer lab to be used by teachers for testing, and 124 out of the 180 school days it is being used for just that – PERT, EOC, FCAT, AP, SAT, ACT, semester exams – when are teachers supposed to have the time to teach? We worry about budget cuts (to an already laughable budget), but while faculty and staff are being laid off and programs cut, the money is being handed away to test makers. These tests give us meaningless figures to show everyone we can that we’re “progressing” but personally I believe we are regressing. And the evaluation systems for both teachers AND students are so ridiculous, it’s as if the public school system is a parody of itself. The pressure a teacher is put under to have all of the correct phrases, learning goals, and “percentile gain” methods on display in their classrooms; I honestly don’t know how they manage to do it. Stopping to have every high school student hold up a hand gesture and gauge their understanding on a lesson every time one is taught, just because these Marzano techniques were highly effective in ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS is, to me, insane. I don’t even know what to do about any of this either aside from hope that someone with power, someone with common sense, someone with a love of EDUCATION, realizes what is going on and decides to take action. Because seeing my teachers crumpling under stress due to the greed of heartless politicians is something that I can hardly stomach.

US Students Rocking the AP Exams

Finally, a little good news. Our top students are knocking the AP exams out of the park. As they should. This is a sharp bunch. Unlike their peers, they watch the news, they know from conversations with their parents that their education is under assault. All eyes are watching them, AND their teachers, to see if they'll be the hero or the zero. But I'm actually not that surprised. As a teacher, I see this everyday. The "honors" kids, to whom I teach chemistry and physics, smirk and shake their heads incredulously at the "other" classes that can't even remember how to calculate D=m/v..."Mr. V, now which one get's divided by which one again? The top or the bottom number?" *sigh* *facepalm* *sigh again* So, why do AP kids seem to just "get it?" As a science teacher, I always ask, "What's the variable?" Current reformists/politicians would like for you to believe that these children MUST have had the best teachers EVERY year which is why they are the BEST students. Just ask an administrator; there is no factor other than instructional quality, which is why all students would be Rhodes Scholars if we could just get these deadbeat teachers to do their damn job! I suppose that's one way to look at it. In fact, it IS the way they currently look at it. But what about this? In my honors class I have two children that come from doctor families, I have one child who is the daughter of the county assistant DA, another who is the son of an engineer at White Sands Missile Range, and a few who are the children of Air Force officers. What's the variable? Sit in a parent/teacher conference with these parents and you'll see the variable very quickly. Engaged, supportive parents who know the value of an education. Couple that WITH superb teaching and you get results like those seen in the aforementioned article. But great teaching without parent support, and parent support without great teaching? Forget it. Education- it's a team sport. Come on parents...let's get on the field...together