Sunday, February 24, 2013

Some 'Cyber Schools' Falling Short

Cyberschool isn't for everyone. I've taken online courses, and while I don't hate them, I much prefer the face-to-face time in a classroom. NPR recently featured a story highlighting K12 . In case you didn't already know, K12 is "the number one choice in K-12 online education programs in America." Apparently, critics see many "irregularities" in their test scores as opposed to the wonderous progress they claim they can make. Administrators and politicians, who looked upon K12 as yet another magic bullet, are disappointed that K12 didn't just fix everything with a wave of their wand. But how are these people surprised?
Here's my personal experience, one that is not too uncommon, say, three to four times a year: A student comes to my class, and doesn't do the assignments, doesn't study, doesn't follow the rules, causes problems, doesn't seek additional after-school tutoring, and on and on and on. Of course during the parent/teacher conference, this is a result of my poor teaching and my over all poor performance as a decent human being in general (I'm mean, I yell, I spit in their faces and kick them in the groin when they try to turn in assignments, and other absurdities.)
The student is then transferred to the other 8th grade science teacher and promptly doesn't do the assignments, doesn't study, doesn't follow the rules, causes problems, doesn't seek additional after-school tutoring, and on and on and on.
"Well," snorts the parent, "It's obvious that you all hate my poor baby. I'm going to home school him/her'" and the parent walks up to the guidance counselor and signs them out of school.
To successfully complete an online course, one needs certain skills and attitudes. Can you work independently? Can you ask questions and be persistent until you find out the information you need? Can you meet a deadline?
Now, think back to our student and parent of the year duo. Do they sound like they possess those kinds of skills? The short answer is, of course, no, and THAT is why they don't succeed IN school or OUT. A student who refuses to work with a teacher lording over them sure as hell isn't going to work while mom is out of the house from 8am-5pm.
And so, inevitably the parent returns the student to us the following new school year (even more behind than ever), complete with how the Cyberschools were "out to get her." Perhaps next time I might just explain to her, "Ma'am, maybe K12 Cyberschools just hates your poor baby....like the rest of us."

No comments:

Post a Comment