Sunday, February 3, 2013
Education is Broken (Part II, or, Where the Teachers at?!))
In an earlier post, I referenced the overall purpose of this blog: "The purpose of 'Alt_Education,' is to examine education as a profession and approach the many issues in education from a logical, rational point of view; from the perspective of an everyday teacher in the trenches (read as: the opposite of what the Ivory Tower education bureaucrats do)"
And while I have written numerous posts on the frustrations that a plain ol' regular teacher experiences from within the system, the issue of the aforementioned ivory tower education bureaucrat experts should be addressed, too. After all, shouldn't we listen to experts? When the President wants military advice, he seeks the wisdom of military leaders; men and women who have experienced the stresses and strains of combat. When one wishes to get medical advice, I should hope that they consult with medical professionals. Again, it seems logical....rational.
Unfortunately, one of the main reasons that our education system cannot seem to find its way, is because that the same common sense approach that I have applied to the previous scenarios is not an approach employed by the Education and Workforce Committee. While at the Education and Workforce Committee website, please click on each member's name, and read about their extensive experience in K-12 public/private school teach...ing...no, actually wait a minute. Don't do that. I must apologize for I'm sure my readers are very busy people. Let me save you some time....wait for it....Not ONE of the 23 members of this committee has EVER been in a K-12 classroom (well, aside from a photo op, I'm sure). Lawyers? Got those! Doctors? There are a couple of them, too. Heck, this committee even has a former helicopter pilot and a Marine artillery officer! Pretty cool, huh? But no teachers.
So, I propose that Washington continue this line of reasoning in ALL of their committees, proceedings, and affairs. Let's stack Homeland Security and the Joint Chiefs of Staff with peace activists from UC Berkeley. Let's put herbal shamen/medicine men/voodoo/faith healers on the medical and healthcare subcommittees. Or, how about filling up the chairs in the Senates Special Committee on Aging with teenagers? Wait, I know! This is the one! Perhaps the House Committee on Intelligence should be appointed with people who aren't actually very intelligent. Actually, I think that last one has been done.
If you've ever wondered, "Why can't we seem to fix our schools," this might be a good place to start. Contact your Congress person and ask, "Why are the power brokers, the decision makers, the politicians, the ones who have never seen the teacher side of a classroom, in charge of education policy?"
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

I'm glad to see you are blogging again after taking a year off. I look forward to reading your thoughts on education.
ReplyDeleteThanks Jack....I enjoy your blog everyday
DeleteYo Jonny - has it ever been determined as to WHY the people that are on the board, are, you know, on the board?
ReplyDeleteCarmen, thanks for the comment. While many people get on the school board because they want to "help the children," most do it because they don't like what they see going on in their schools, and they want to affect change. That's good AND bad. Good because community involvement is important in a public school, but bad because most of these people have little, if any, teaching/education policy experience.
DeleteAnother reason people "run for the board" is to push their own agenda(s). Look at the school boards in Kansas and Texas that have been packed with evangelical extremists. Their purpose is to fight evolution in science texts, and "liberal bias" in the history books.
http://www2.ljworld.com/news/2013/jan/16/state-education-board-eyes-new-social-studies-stan/
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/13/education/13texas.html?_r=0